Week 3 Blog
As we discussed in class this week, the United States government includes Congress, the Presidency, Courts, States, and Tribes. Generally speaking, Indigenous groups (generally classified under tribes) are often less well-known in United States governance. Issues involving Indigenous groups will frequently fail to receive as much publicity on a national level as issues governed by Supreme Court cases or other federal institutions. However, tribal governance plays a very important role in policy decisions, especially in regard to environmental issues.
One example, which I read a book on for another class, is the opposition of the Gwich’in people to oil drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge as the caribou, who represent their ways of life and land, calve in the specific area and, therefore, their existence could be put in jeopardy with the opening of the area to oil drilling. Throughout this fight, the Gwich’in have held a large amount of power and have carried significant weight in the decision-making process.
Another example can be found in my hometown of Juneau, Alaska. Currently, different Indigenous corporations have raised concerns over the management of tourism in Southeast Alaska. Specifically, large-scale cruise ship tourism takes place in ports like Juneau, Ketchikan, and Skagway. These ports are without much Indigenous presence, an issue inspiring Native corporations to increase tourism in order to increase their presence within the industry. However, other Indigenous groups oppose this increase in tourism as it has been shown to have detrimental environmental impacts. These groups, along with other environmental groups, are lobbying to decrease cruise tourism in the Tongass National Rainforest.
Tribes are sovereign nations, yet their authority over land and environmental policy, specifically, remains constrained by the greater federal government. This leads to a checks and balances system that ensures that tribal governments have a say in the greater workings of the federal and state governments, without having unconstrained freedom to alter or endanger environmental processes on their land.
One example, which I read a book on for another class, is the opposition of the Gwich’in people to oil drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge as the caribou, who represent their ways of life and land, calve in the specific area and, therefore, their existence could be put in jeopardy with the opening of the area to oil drilling. Throughout this fight, the Gwich’in have held a large amount of power and have carried significant weight in the decision-making process.
Another example can be found in my hometown of Juneau, Alaska. Currently, different Indigenous corporations have raised concerns over the management of tourism in Southeast Alaska. Specifically, large-scale cruise ship tourism takes place in ports like Juneau, Ketchikan, and Skagway. These ports are without much Indigenous presence, an issue inspiring Native corporations to increase tourism in order to increase their presence within the industry. However, other Indigenous groups oppose this increase in tourism as it has been shown to have detrimental environmental impacts. These groups, along with other environmental groups, are lobbying to decrease cruise tourism in the Tongass National Rainforest.
Tribes are sovereign nations, yet their authority over land and environmental policy, specifically, remains constrained by the greater federal government. This leads to a checks and balances system that ensures that tribal governments have a say in the greater workings of the federal and state governments, without having unconstrained freedom to alter or endanger environmental processes on their land.
3 replies on “Week 3 Blog”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Gwen, thank you for your insight.
I agree that Indigenous groups are critical for environmental decisions but lack proper power and respect. I find it interesting Native corporations were pressured to increase tourism just to be able to have a voice in that realm, as if corporate messages are the only ones heard in our government.
Great post, Gwen. I feel the presence of Native Tribes in government is incredibly valuable and necessary, especially when land management is involved. However, the balance between representation and conservation is always tricky, as you mentioned above. I feel that Indigenous people have come a long way in terms of government representation, but, Like Emma said, there is still an incredible amount of work to be done.
Hi Gwen,
Being from Southeast Alaska also, I understand how big tourism is and how it can both positively and negatively impact communities who experience it. In Glacier Bay, the National Park Service have carved out many areas for the Huna T’lingit to have a voice that must be heard and worked with in order for more progress in the park. While some of these changes work well with current operations, like including a ceremony to respect the trees being cut down for development in the front country, other requests are much more complicated and difficult to accomplish, like the desire for the T’lingit to be able to hunt and fish free of regulations and to be able to built seasonal fish camps in the bay. This system is no where near perfect and there are some wrongs we can no longer undo, but I see changes like this as hope that Indigenous voices will continue to be amplified in a place where large billion dollar corporations and federal agencies rule.