Week 3 Response: Tribal Co-Stewardship

Tribal co-stewardship, like many other progressive buzzwords, has been thrown around frequently in recent years in the environmental sphere as a sign of progress and inclusivity. But, does it mean more than a signed document to prove governmental reconciliation efforts? Or is it simply another set of performative actions? What are the goals of tribes in these co-stewardship efforts, and what power do these tribes hold?

In the most general sense, a co-stewardship agreement is a signed document that shows that the federal agency in charge of land management and the Tribe or people that have historically cared for the area share common goals in preserving or utilizing the land. Individual examples of these agreements have existed for decades between parks and specific tribes, but the first large-scale recognition of Tribal influence and interests over federally protected lands was in the Joint Secretarial Order in 2021 between the Department of the Interior and the Department of Agriculture (Order 3403). While this order sets in motion the potential for actions by these departments, very little power is given to sovereign Tribal nations themselves. Instead, this document mostly enforces regulations for how to conduct meetings with tribes and how to take their interests into consideration, which could have varying impacts depending on interpretation. Some portions of it, depending on how seriously it is enforced, could have major impacts: deadlines for major change within 1 year of the order, protecting and keeping confidential sacred Indian sites, including Tribal lands in watershed restoration, and consolidating Tribal inholdings and claims. This Secretarial Order was further set in stone by the creation of four more site-specific co-stewardship agreements in 2022 based on the precedent set by Order 3403. While firm regulations are not in place for how future agreements and consultations will proceed, this initial action is certainly hopeful for future tribal interests and potential stewardship of federal lands.

While signing this document was a significant milestone for the Biden administration, it remains to be seen how a new Trump administration will interpret Order 3403. With Trump’s main policy goals being to reduce government spending and roll back DEI initiatives, and with his pick for DOI Secretary, Doug Burgum, being a major proponent of coal and gas, there is a strong possibility that co-stewardship progress will stall, if not halt entirely, in future administrations. While leadership changes may significantly impact the DOI and USDA, many park and conservation site managers are likely to remain in place, allowing for continued small-scale collaboration. 

Co-stewardship | u. S. Department of the interior. (2023, November 29). [Site page]. https://www.doi.gov/ppa/what-we-do/trust-obligation/co-stewardship

Joint Secretarial Order on Fulfilling the Trust Responsibility to Indian Tribes in the Stewardship of Federal Lands and Waters , 5 (2021).

Interior department issues guidance to strengthen tribal co-stewardship of public lands and waters | u. S. Department of the interior. (2022, September 13). [Press Release]. https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/interior-department-issues-guidance-strengthen-tribal-co-stewardship-public-lands-and

3 replies on “Week 3 Response: Tribal Co-Stewardship”

  1. China Kantner on

    Hey Lily! I appreciate you bringing this topic up. I worked for the National Park Service when this directive came out and I remember being excited, yet confused about how much impact the order could really have. One of my first reactions was about how few tribes might actually be able to participate due to their limited capacity. Tribes in the Northwest Arctic (where I live) often have a hard enough time between staffing and funding issues to maintain their programs and services. While I believe land stewardship is within the expertise of tribal governments, it seems like tribes would need additional funding and staff in order to communicate with the federal government the way they expect.

  2. Emma Sulczynski on

    Hi Lily, thank you for touching on this topic. The environmental movement has had many issues in the past for its exclusivity and lack of intersectional considerations, though there has been more of a push in recent years towards climate justice and approaches that take diverse and interconnected issues into account. I believe that Tribal sovereignty and inclusion of Indigenous peoples, who have often been stewards of the land for far longer than this country has existed, are incredibly important subjects if we are to address climate change and environmental issues in an equitable way. It is of course an incredibly complicated matter to navigate in coordination with local, state, and federal agencies, and one that may be further burdened by partisanship and the political goals of the new administration, but I hope that we see more effort to this end in the future.

  3. AJ Hytry on

    I’m not very familiar with tribal co-stewardships, so this was a great bit of information. It’s unfortunate the openness to interpretation, since this never seems to play out well in the government. Great point bringing up how the Trump administration may affect co-stewardships in the future.

Leave a Reply