Week 3 Post: Traditional Cultural Properties

I recently learned about the concept of Traditional Cultural Properties. These are places that are included in the National Historic Register for their connection to cultural practices and beliefs. To designate a TCP, one must certify its cultural significance through historical documents, interviews, archeological reports, etc. When a federal or federally assisted project occurs in or a near a TCP, it triggers consultation with the tribe or group that designated the property but it does not necessarily mean that the project will be stopped due to its cultural significance.

Some people in the Upper Kobuk who are against the Ambler Road want to protect the entire Ambler River or entire Kobuk River from this kind of development. TCPs have been presented as a way to achieve this.

I’ve heard two stories lately that make me question whether it would be worthwhile to designate a river in the Upper Kobuk as a TCP. One comes from the experience of the Native Villages of Teller and Brevig Mission with the Graphite One project. In this case, the villages were not properly consulted about the project because the project isn’t on tribal lands, TCPs, or federal lands. Designating a TCP in this case would trigger project consultation with those tribes going forward.

In the case of Upper Kobuk tribes and the Ambler Road, there are already federal lands, Native corporation lands, native allotments and TCPs in the area that trigger tribal consultation, not to mention the fact that ANILCA requires analysis of the subsistence impacts to the Upper Kobuk villages due to their proximity to 3 National Park units and 1 National Wildlife Refuge. Even if D-1 lands around the Haul Road were conveyed to the State, the road developer would have its work cut out to make a circuitous, if even possible route, to avoid hitting tribal lands.

Another village in Alaska recently designated an entire watershed as TCP and ran into extreme hurdles in dealing with the State Historic Preservation Office—for six long years. Later, when it came time to draw the official boundaries of the TCP, the US Army Corps of Engineers also proved to be a difficult partner. I’m not entirely clear on the details here, but I wonder if the complexities of the WOTUS rule and the current state debate over the mean high water level and big game hunting came into play. In the end, the project the tribe was trying to fight was approved anyway.

Again, in the case of the Ambler Road, the sheer complexity of creating a TCP is a serious drawback. This means using the tribes’ precious time and money for a something that doesn’t guarantee protection. I think those resources could be better used toward another project at this point in time. To what project is the question.  

Leave a Reply