Week 3 Response – Tension Between State and Federal Government

The United States system of governance involves the federal government acting at a national level and operating within states, and individual state governments exercising authority over their territory and the issues within their purview. This model naturally creates some tension between federal and state government as the federal government tries to exercise its authority across each state as a national institution and state governments advocate for approaches that suit their individual needs and interests. The former is tasked with finding regulations and policies that work across the board without putting any one regional party at a disproportionate disadvantage while the latter must take action on its state-specific issues while being mindful of federal authority. There are many cases where state and federal authority overlaps, so both must find ways to collaborate and share power.

When it comes to environmental policies, this tension can show up in a number of ways. For those of us in Alaska, many policies that would benefit or be well suited to the Lower 48 may have a drastically different effect here. When visiting D.C. through a Climate Scholars program to learn about influencing federal climate policy, the organizations and government officials that we met with often emphasized the importance of educating officials on Alaska’s unique characteristics and advocating for its specific issues because so many policymakers are entirely ignorant of our circumstances. Without Alaskan voices present, federal policies would not reflect our distinctive needs (such as tailored responses reflective of our status as the only Arctic state and the state most affected by global warming.)

Here in Fairbanks, we have repeatedly been in violation of the Clean Air Act due to PM 2.5 pollution. It has been a long fight between local government and the Environmental Protection Agency, which is tasked with developing and enforcing air pollution standards. They have imposed sanctions for failure to meet air pollution standards and denied plans put forward to address air pollution, resulting in years of conflict. However, this may be resolved soon as they indicate approval for the most recent air pollution reduction plan.

2 replies on “Week 3 Response – Tension Between State and Federal Government”

  1. AJ Hytry on

    Alaska is a good example of State and Federal needing to discuss how general guidelines can’t simply be applied everywhere. Not only is this true in air quality, but also in water quality. However, it is the Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation that implements control strategies. The state sends proposals to EPA, demonstrating a plan towards meeting Ambient Air Quality Standards. They also ensure compliance. EPA does set national regulations states are required to follow, but the state demonstrates how they are going to meet requirements.

  2. Lily Hooge on

    Hi Emma,
    Thank you for your post. While I knew about the air pollution issues in Fairbanks, I had no idea that the reason for such delayed actions was because of conflict between federal agencies and local governments. One reason I think that Alaska especially has historically had so much tension while working with the federal government is because of the large libertarian political base in Alaska. Many people from Democrats to Republicans to Independents in the Alaska political sphere value privacy and a reduction in federal regulations much more than many other states. I imagine in the perspective of many Alaskans, the federal government, who, as you mentioned, is often misinformed on Alaskan issues, seems like a clumsy toddler knocking down regulations and policies already tailored for our state.

Leave a Reply