Week 3- The States Interest In Passing and Enforcing Policy

Congress people promise their voters that they will support issues that directly benefit their community. Because of this, representatives and senators are, regarding many issues, in opposition to each other. Obtaining funding and opportunities for their states is how congress people rely on being reelected, so any proposed bills pose a threat. Every passed bill is possibly millions or billions of dollars of the federal budget that their state does not have immediate and exclusive access to. Other bills may offer this commodity, so legislators are more apt to give them their support. Legislators work together to give and get commodities for each other’s states. Even regional alliances exist; geographical proximity plays a role in legislators voting together. 

Regardless of the merits of legislation, it is common for legislators to place preference on bills with the most advantage for their state. Environmental legislation is traditionally a large package of guidelines for pollution, species conservation, waste cleanup, etc. Because this is nationally encompassing, individual states’ interest is minimal. Despite the legislation being beneficial overall, it is difficult to pass bills that are full of guidelines that may economically burden states rather than benefit them immediately. 

Not only is passing federal legislation a battle, but enforcing it is optional for states. No matter the decisions of congress, if state officials do not see it as benefiting them or their population votes in opposition, they are not required to enforce the federal law. This is why it is valuable for individual states to pass their own environmental legislation. Many environmental issues are regional anyway; site-specific waste dumping, local air pollution, and litter are some issues that would be most effectively dealt with by local governments that have the most interest and knowledge about the situation. 

Federal legislators have a duty to protect their states’ future by supporting bills that solve their problems immediately. However, foresight into the climatic future of their communities is imperative. Now, federal environmental policy is next to impossible to efficiently pass. State governments need self awareness that for effective change, their action is crucial.    

3 replies on “Week 3- The States Interest In Passing and Enforcing Policy”

  1. Nicholas Alexander on

    Environmental policy undoubtedly plays a crucial role in our government. However, the hijacking of NEPA by extreme environmental groups has hindered progress, often stalling legislation more than facilitating it. When states try to pass responsible laws, they want to avoid the risk of projects being delayed for decades by endless legal battles before they’re even approved.

  2. James Carr on

    Hello, Charlee. That’s an important point to keep in mind. Senators and representatives have different although overlapping constituencies and this makes it challenging to know what is most closely aligned with the will of their supporters. It also can pit the two houses of Congress against each other. As you mentioned, it can be difficult if not impossible for the diverse voters across the country to find common ground and this can really stifle the ability of Congress to pass effective legislation while still voting according to the will of their constituents. It seems like the core issue of a lot of environmental policy at the federal level is that it’s difficult to get people across the country to see solutions to problems in one part of the country as relevant to them. On the one hand, it makes sense why someone would argue that environmental protections should be enacted primarily by the states instead of by the federal government. On the other, issues like air and water pollution do not stay within the borders of one state. The public should be made aware of how interconnected local environmental issues are, which would hopefully result in Congress being able to find more common ground on environmental protection legislation without alienating their supporters.

  3. Clint Cole on

    Charlee, you have given important points with regard to the importance of National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) role in shaping implementation of the projects. It is important to note, however, that environmental legislation do struggle to gain the needed congressional support to enable individual states to benefit as required. Legislators give priority to the laws that have direct benefit to their electorate to enable them to receive support that they need during elections making important environmental policies or laws hard to pass. States also may resist or become reluctant to implement federal laws that may have economic implications and this derail proper adoption and implementation of environmemtal policies.

Leave a Reply