Week 4- Is Environmental Democracy Possible?
Should environmental issues be democratic? This is on my mind because if climate scientists were dictating elections, then the country would have extremely different leadership. For example, there would be educated debates about how to solve environmental issues, and they would lead to impactful solutions. Instead, uninformed people with no qualifications question if the science is “real,” and this affects elections greatly. It is proving to be dangerous to operate under this system, and I believe that a big change is needed.
It’s wonderful to have a society where everyone has a voice, but how can people be so arrogant to believe that they should be more trusted with environmental information than an accredited scientist? This is where the issue is. The United States’ political system does not blend with environmental politics- it creates controversy around issues with seemingly obvious solutions. Elections are the beginning of the problem. They turn into a vicious cycle of instability and ingenuine promises. Party control changes, and bills the previous legislature passed can be modified or overturned. This oscillation of opinions makes environmental democracy an impossible reality.
It is undeniable that the environment controls people, and it is time to respect that truth. Without legislation that provides effective change, the environment will continue to show itself to be uncooperative with the way humans have harmed it. Fast, informed legislation is the only sensible way to move forward, and the most immediate solution would be a structure change of the government that prioritizes scientists’ opinions. This would require a removal of some democratic rights, but it would help solidify a healthier future.
4 replies on “Week 4- Is Environmental Democracy Possible?”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Hi Charlee, thank you for your insight.
I agree; I also find it odd when I hear people question if science, such as global warming, is “real.” However, after reading Jasanoff, 1996 I could understand why our society treats science as a debate. After years of seeing horror in the news and personal life, we are all on edge. I especially found it interesting to read how we lack a cultural community. I think a lack of identity from a community could be why we see people clinging to the culture that political parties have created. This may be why people are so quick to say certain science isn’t “real”. So yes, climate scientists making decisions would change our government and the outcome of our environmental world. However, people would be utterly outraged. Is that any different than reproductive rights being taken in some states? So, if the government were to allow scientists to make scientific decisions there would be more distrust. Is trusting the government necessary for democracy or even regular life?
Hi Charlee, I think you bring up such an important point. I love how you said “if climate scientists were dictating elections, then the country would have extremely different leadership.” It’s absolutely true. I feel like people are so quick to form opinions from an uninformed and uneducated place, and that in and of itself is the downfall of our democracy. Misinformation and a serious lack of education.
Hi Charlee, Science should absolutely play a huge role in decision-making. But I also think we need to consider things like cultural norms, global impacts, and how policies affect everyday people. For example, look at the passage of Prohibition. Scientifically, alcohol is harmful to both people and society, but banning it completely didn’t work. It ignored social and economic realities, which is why the 21st Amendment brought it back.
The idea of science-driven policy sounds appealing. Especially when it comes to prominent issues like climate change. But could removing democratic input actually create new problems? If we let only scientists make the rules, what happens when policies clash with social or economic needs?
Hi,
One important aspect that might be brought up is religious influences; even among politicians and scientists, there are bound to bias. Additionally, I think we should discuss how some of what scientists are producing as fact often rely on assumptions of what is coming in the future. The environment can be very difficult to control, and it is then more difficult to decide who gets to try. Both of the things I mention, I think, have been discussed when determining who gets to choose where environmental control/protection is heading.