Week 4: NEPA & Environmental Democracy
This week, we learned about NEPA and environmental democracy. While I personally believe democracy is an important aspect of our decision-making processes, a few themes came up throughout our reading that really stuck with me. Trust, integrity, and education. Unfortunately, as many have already pointed out in their posts, scientifically-educated/informed (including Indigenous peoples, who may have different methods of collecting data, yet are no less credible) citizens voices are not often heard. Business people, economists, and opinionated people with money are typically those who are heard by politicians, and policies are tailored to their needs. If we were a slightly more elevated and open-minded society, I believe we could reach common ground and compromise when filling a room with educated and informed citizens of different backgrounds. Unfortunately, time and again it is clearly exemplified that we are unable to achieve that. This leads to mistrust in our government from the vast majority of citizens, as well as a loss of hope for those who understand how crucial environmental conservation is to furthering our society and expanding our ways of life. This lack of integrity, in the inability to find a balanced compromise, is what keeps us stuck.
This brings me to the importance of education. NEPA was originally established to give people a voice in our government, and yet it favors voices who see scientific data and research as a theological belief system rather than a set of ever expanding knowledge of how our planet works. They fail to see that this research is being done not only for conservation purposes, but for the purpose of being able to continue our industrialized lifestyle, and help it flourish rather than trying to shut it all down. But if we keep exploiting our planet, there won’t be anywhere to have said industry, and it was all essentially for nothing. Finding environmentally friendly solutions and practices quite literally benefits everyone and everything. Unfortunately, there is a severe lack of education about the way government works, the way businesses work, the way the environment works, in our society. In schools, these courses are electives, many students electing to bypass them for classes they feel are more important. There is little to no community information on these topics, and if there is, it is marketed to those who already have an interesting such things. I think if true environmental democracy is ever to even be considered, education needs to be mandatory to those of the 1%, those voices that are heard. And it needs to begin earlier on, when minds are more open. Otherwise, genuinely nothing will change because money will trump environmental needs every single time if given the option.
3 replies on “Week 4: NEPA & Environmental Democracy”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Do you think educational systems should start to implement classes regarding climate change and how we can reduce our carbon footprint? There’s no denying that climate change has become a big industry, but in college its not really discussed much unless sought out by the student. I once came to a similar conclusions as you when it came to obesity in America.
Hi Ilona, you bring up an important point re: lack of education. The readings we discussed this week made me think a lot about the topic of public education and how it pertains to how people participate in their government and the world around them. Education is such a vital part of a healthy and well-rounded society, and seeing the growing movement to defund and devalue educational institutions and police the content they teach is something of great concern to our collective future. Environmental democracy is an admirable and worthwhile goal, but we will never be able to achieve it without a population capable of understanding and meaningfully participating in this system.
Thanks for this post Ilona! I agree with you that education around civics and climate change is really important and we need to do a better job of this in K-12.
I’m often reminded of the progressive movement of the early 1900s. There were calls for the need for education around voting and civic engagement to root out the Tammany Hall and Boss Tweed style politics. This was billed as a “progressive” movement, but in reality it was rooted in racism toward white ethnics (Italians, Jews, Eastern/Southern Europeans) who were gaining political power, albeit with a lot of graft involved.
I’m not at all saying that environmental democracy is rooted in a similar thing, but I keep this in mind as kind of a, what are the unintended consequences question. I find that rather than saying these people are uneducated on these large matters, it can make more sense to meet them where they are at and provide them with the answers and materials that they want in specific situations that are close to home for them. For example, a specific election or development project in their borough or state can be an awakening to a larger cause.