Environmental Democracy

There are many long standing arguments against the idea of democracy as a form of government, many examples of inflated conflict, failed policy, and stymied progress. The masses have no wisdom, they lack intelligence and are easily manipulated; people vote against both their self- and national-interest. Professional technocrats should wield a more measured hand, well scholared and trained to carry out these difficult tasks; a unified state should act without internal discord to a properly set goal. Such an area as environmental policy makes this view extremely easy; such times as these seem to prove it out.

However, such a view, I think, is flawed: it assumes that the public and the professionals are mutually separated and incompatible. The fact is scientists and actors of professional policy do not live within some secret deep-state camp: they are members of the public whom live in our towns and cities the same as any other professionals. As someone currently going through a biology degree plan, I know well that the specifics of environmental science, ecology, and conservation are quite complex and often outside of ‘common sense’, but they are not unlearnable nor unteachable. More importantly, the methods by which they are proven out are not unlearnable either.

The most coined joke for the failure of the education system is something about “the mitochondria is the powerhouse of the cell”. It’s a phrase often symbolizing how we are systematically taught things about biology with a top-down approach, memorizing specific phrases from the state standardized test with little reason to parse out how they come about and how they might be used. Due to the limit of what a school can do in one hour of a day, science has been taught without respect for the curiosity and critical thinking that builds it up until you’ve reached college, and even then it is only taught for those looking to gain entry. While I do believe that scientists and intellectual organizations have done a good job of showing the public its findings, there has been a large gap, yes in the raw knowledge needed to parse through it, but even more so in the style of critical thinking through which it was produced. We have failed to develop a public that thinks like a scientist thinks, and so it can be no wonder as to why they have turned their backs on the scientists who, from their view, make no sense and insist they have all the answers.

As we read what Mitchell had wrote, we found that there are forces that make environmental democracy hard. The public must be educated, united, and humble, weary of the forces that would see environmental destruction for personal gain. And in today’s climate it would seem that has been failed, but I do not think this is the inevitable outcome. Bleak as things seem now, we have not yet lost either our democracy nor our environment. While we still can, we have to make efforts to show our friends, family, and nation, not just what science has to offer, but also how it had come to offer it. The critique of academia from the distinctly American strand of anti-intellectualism is not correct in many ways, it it might have a slicer of truth in accusing it of arrogantly insisting upon its worth without revealing itself and its nature. Beyond all, we must not yet lose hope. My favorite book has always been “You Can’t Go Home Again” by Thomas Wolfe, for in it I have found many lives and many proverbs; one I’ve kept much in mind these days is the following from the opening chapter:

“And great Goethe, accepting the inevitable truth that human growth does not proceed in a straight line to its goal, had compared the development and progress of mankind to the reelings of a drunken beggar on horseback.

What was important, perhaps, was not that the beggar was drunk and reeling, but that he was mounted on his horse, and, however unsteadily, was going somewhere.”

I think we all feel as though humanity has one again stumbled back, and for a moment we question what is the moral arc of the universe? It is hard to say, but it is best that we keep going somewhere, and keep going there with hope.

One reply on “Environmental Democracy”

  1. China Kantner on

    I really enjoyed reading your post Ryan! Your last comment I think is something that we ALL can agree on–Trump supporter, working class, woke, etc. We have stumbled back. I think we often see media that talks about how divided we are, but every once in a while I stumble upon a study that points out that actually we strongly agree on a lot of key points. These points feel like a good place to start.

Leave a Reply