The Difference In Land Management at the State Level and the Federal Level

The purpose of public land is complex. Now, it is meant for recreation and conservation. Decades ago, public lands were used as an inventory of products that the government could sell. Through logging and mining, the federal government made a large profit off of selling resources that it owned. It wasn’t until unrest from environmentalists over the extirpation of the northern spotted owl that logging stopped. This gave way to a new way of management that we know today. The most popular federal lands, National Parks, are visited by millions yearly. Forest Service and BLM land is less popular, yet it is still managed and preserved for the public. Federal conservation of public lands is important to maintaining biodiversity in the United States.

The management of public lands by the states is very different from the federal government. I have experience working as a habitat employee for the state of South Dakota. This position opened my eyes to what management can mean. South Dakota’s most important game species for tourism and revenue is the ring-necked pheasant. This game bird is not native anywhere in the United States, and suitable habitat in the state is almost nonexistent among the acres of agricultural fields. The public land management strategy is to plant grain for the birds to eat and to create habitat for them to live in. This experience showed me that management does not have to mean conservation. These public lands are still used as a way of creating revenue, which is similar to forest service land management in the time of logging. This is not a controversial issue in South Dakota, but I believe that prairie restoration should be the top priority for public land management. I hope this issue begins to be taken into consideration.

2 replies on “The Difference In Land Management at the State Level and the Federal Level”

  1. Ilona Bartnicki on

    Hi Charlee, I like the way you depict the business side of public lands – how it has become a ‘product for sale.’ I find the treatment of land this way incredibly insensitive. Not only to the Indigenous peoples who once called it home and are fighting to get it back, but also to the plant and animal species, like the ring-necked pheasant you mentioned, who are being forced out of their habitats in much the same way. I too hope that in the future we can see more conservation alongside management. The two can most definitely coexist.

  2. Chloe P on

    Hi Charlee! I enjoyed reading your post. I appreciated that you shouted out owls surrounding the forestry issue while highlighting the fact that heavy development of natural resources is what mainly drove the US to utilize public lands in the first place. This reminded me of the fact that I remember natural resources always, since I was little, being touted as a kind of limited resource, which gave me bouts of anxiety as a child. Even from a young age, armed with the knowledge that resources were finite, I wondered how people just kept using energy, cars, and gas. Obviously, the true scale of the world wasn’t apparent to me at that age, but as I’ve grown older that unease has not completely abated. Good post, Charlee!

Leave a Reply