Public Lands: America’s Greatest Asset or Its Next Big Sellout? Week 7
America’s public lands are supposed to belong to everyone, but lately, they feel more like a prize in a high-stakes political and corporate tug-of-war. On one side, conservationists and Indigenous groups fight to protect national parks, forests, and monuments from overdevelopment. On the other, energy companies, ranchers, and even billionaires see these lands as untapped resources or private playgrounds. With every administration, policies shift—sometimes expanding protections, sometimes slashing them in the name of economic growth. The question is, how much longer will these lands stay truly public?
Energy companies have long had their sights set on public lands, pushing for more drilling, mining, and logging. Under Trump, millions of acres were opened for extraction, with national monuments like Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante significantly reduced in size. Biden reversed many of these rollbacks, but the battle is far from over. Even as new leases are paused, lawsuits and political maneuvering keep the fight alive. Meanwhile, ranchers—like those involved in the infamous Bundy standoff—continue to challenge federal authority, arguing they should have unrestricted access to grazing lands without paying fees.
But industry isn’t the only force threatening public access. Wealthy landowners are buying up massive tracts, fencing off areas once open to the public. Hunting and fishing groups are raising alarms about traditional lands being cut off, while national park fees continue to rise, turning once-accessible landscapes into exclusive retreats for those who can afford them. Public lands are slowly becoming less public, whether through privatization or paywalls that price out the average American.
At the heart of the issue is Indigenous land rights, which have been overlooked for generations. Many of these “public” lands were originally taken from Native tribes, and now, Indigenous groups are leading efforts to reclaim stewardship. The fight over Bears Ears is a prime example, where tribes successfully pressured the government to restore protections after Trump’s cuts. But this is just one victory in a much larger struggle—one where tribes are still having to justify why they deserve a say in managing their own ancestral lands.
As climate change accelerates and development pressures grow, the fate of public lands is more uncertain than ever. Will they remain a shared national treasure, or will they be chipped away piece by piece until there’s nothing left? The fight isn’t just about land—it’s about who holds power in America’s future.
2 replies on “Public Lands: America’s Greatest Asset or Its Next Big Sellout? Week 7”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Hi Jenna, great post! I think you make an excellent point with the fight over who hold’s power in America’s future. With our ever-changing leadership system, I wonder if stability is something that is possible to achieve – where all parties are considered and managed in as balanced a way as possible. While it’s impossible to make everyone happy all of the time, I do feel that if we had better choices in political leaders, and enough education as a society to elect them, we may see less of a constant struggle.
Hi Jenna, thanks for you post! I think the overturn of the Chevron doctrine last year adds to the sell off of public lands. If regulatory agencies aren’t able to fulfill their missions and regulate, it is too easy for private companies to do as they please on Americans’ public lands.
I’m not as familiar with the pricing issue of National Parks. When I worked for the Park Service in Kotzebue though, I was struck by Park Passport crowd. These are folks of many backgrounds, though largely retired and white, who travel all around the country to see the 66 national parks, or even the 420-something national park units (including monuments, preserves, etc). Reading your post, I can’t help but wonder if the type of trip this group is after, plus the amount of money they bring along with them, shapes National Parks’ activities or if it’s the other way around.