Week 7: Public Lands Conflicts

This week, we spent time learning about public lands conflicts. After our first assignment this semester analyzing presidencies, I found myself quite interested in the ANWR conflict. President Biden protected over 13 million acres in that area, while President Trump has expressed his interest in scaling that back so it can be drilled for oil. The smaller tribal community of the ANWR has expressed how vital that area is for subsistence hunting and Porcupine caribou migration routes, and more. However, a tribe of that size simply does not have the resources to stand up to big oil.

This made me think of the Cape Wind ordeal, and how the wealthy folks protecting their views benefited the Mashpee Wampanoag tribe of Cape Cod, as well as many locals who opposed the project. The wealth found in Cape Cod is enough to rival big energy. As is the wealth surrounding Yellowstone, Glacier, and other national parks. It’s interesting to see the ways public land is often protected in a secondhand way from development by wealthy people protecting their views. I feel as though NIMBY is constantly criticized in politics, as are wealthy folks, but this is a great example of how it can benefit conservation and all those affected by it through a trickle-down tactic.

3 replies on “Week 7: Public Lands Conflicts”

  1. China Kantner on

    You make a good point about NIMBY issues so often being decried by media and opposition groups. (I thought it was a great line in the Cape Spin! film: “how big do these people think their backyard is?!”) In activism, I’ve often thought about how to reframe issues so that they do not get labeled as NIMBY. The best way that I have come across is NIABY: “not in anyone’s backyard.” No tailings ponds in anyone’s backyard. This is definitely more moldable into a positive concept in conservation issues than in affordable housing.

  2. Charlee Galvin on

    Hello Ilona! I like that your post brings up the issue of wealthy people having a stronger voice than tribes and local people with land distribution. When it comes to public lands conflicts, the people most directly influenced do not have their voices heard. Not only does the federal government have massive power over public land, but NGOs do as well. This leads to unjust resolutions over public land conflicts.

  3. Elijah Spencer on

    You mention a paradox—affluent communities inadvertently safeguard public land, as with ANWR and Cape Wind. Must conservation, therefore, be dependent on the powerful and wealthy? Though their opposition has an environmental dividend, it also entrenches inequity, further disenfranchising Native peoples and small communities.

    How can we secure the safeguarding of public lands in a manner that prioritizes every voice and not only the rich? Do local communities and Indigenous people need greater protection in land planning?

Leave a Reply