Week 7 Blog
While doing the readings for this week, I came across a quote in Rosenbaum’s book that seems to encapsulate the conundrum of public lands conflicts. Rosenbaum asserts that “states are often guilty of doublethink” and that they “often seek an ideal, and often elusive, balance between resource development and environmental protection and waiver between supporting and opposing new federal land designations” (page 246). This contradiction lies at the heart of why public land issues continue to be politically and legally troublesome. With each new administration, public land priorities can shift dramatically, from opening lands for oil and gas to restoring and reaffirming conservation protections and goals. Chapter nine provides examples of these dramatic shifts, such as the transition from President Bill Clinton to President George W. Bush. Clinton angered the states of the West when he chose to make 43 acres of national forests off-limits for road construction, which in turn halted any potential economic development. However, this was turned on its head when President Bush took office, as Bush had the opposite motivations for public land, prioritizing “domestic energy development”. Bush hired people just as keen as he was to change the laws around public land, back to the pre-Clinton era. This see-saw pattern has pretty much continued with Presidents Obama, Trump, and Biden. At this point, the battle over public land appears destined to remain a tug of war between past and current administrations, with little consistency from One Presidential term to the next.