Week 2 Response
President Biden faced most challenges that were highlighted in the Rusty Patched bumblebee scenario from chapter 2 in Rosenbaum’s textbook “Environmental Politics and Policy”. From dealing with different agencies to judicial intervention to stakeholder pressures, President Bident ran into similar issues. Environmental law and policy are extremely complex and emotionally charged. Especially so when considering the courts, special interest groups, and Congress
With Biden having a slim to no majority in any chamber of Congress, there were few legislative victories Biden could claim in his 4 years on environmental issues. Most of Biden’s successes came from administrative law, such as executive orders or agency policy/rule changes. For example, the Department of Interior actioned to protect 12.5 million acres of public lands across 12 ranges and areas in 2023. This was done through the Secretary of Interior and President Biden without needing the approval of Congress or the scrutiny of the courts. This is a common tactic of presidents when their legislative agendas are blocked. One concern about executive orders is they can be repealed or replaced by another administration. This can be examined via the fight over the Bears Ears National Monument designation.
Judicial proceedings have a large impact on environmental policy. Individuals, Interest Groups, states, and the federal government will take each other to judicial proceedings to further their agenda and/or gain further clarification from the courts. We see this played out in many different ways from land use to endangered species. An example of this is the current litigation between the state of Texas and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. The State of Texas feels as if the US Fish and Wildlife Service has overstepped in the way they are listing endangered species by not taking into account Texas’s conservation plans (Attorney General Ken Paxton Sues Biden-Harris Administration Over Unlawful Weaponization of Environmental Law, n.d.). The Judicial process is a long and expensive avenue that often implements long-term changes. However, with the adoption of the 2024 Loper Decision by the Supreme Court, the judicial landscape and practices may change drastically.
President Biden’s environmental agenda has seen mixed results in his 4 years. Almost all of his protective laws and actions were made via executive orders or agency decrees. Although these actions created an immediate impact, the sustained result will be questionable with a new Trump administration taking over and possibly overturning most of Biden’s executive actions.
REFERENCES
Attorney General Ken Paxton Sues Biden-Harris Administration Over Unlawful Weaponization of Environmental Law. (n.d.). Texas Attorney General. https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/news/releases/attorney-general-ken-paxton-sues-biden-harris-administration-over-unlawful-weaponization