Week 2 Response
Sam Hananel’s article, “The Biden Administration Has Reached Conservation Records in 2023,” initially presents a compelling and optimistic view of President Joe Biden’s environmental achievements. However, it falls short in addressing whether many of these initiatives will have lasting impacts or survive beyond his administration. With legislative and judicial progress stagnating in recent years, presidents have increasingly relied on executive orders to achieve their campaign goals. While this approach allows for quick action, it weakens the longevity of policies, as they are vulnerable to reversal by future administrations.
While the Biden administration did push for significant conservation progress, most of these actions were not only done through executive order but done in reaction to President Trump’s executive actions during his first term. Now, these lands are once again open to protections being withdrawn with a new Trump administration only just dawning. Furthermore, Hananel focuses heavily on Biden’s well-supported land protection initiatives, while overlooking the administration’s more controversial environmental challenges, such as reducing oil and gas dependence. As Rosenbaum pointed out in chapter 2, companies, environmental radicals, BINGO environmental groups, politicians, labor unions, civil servants, and scientists push conflicting agendas, making true innovative change difficult if not impossible. In times like these, it can be necessary to go the route of executive orders so as to not risk a lack of any change at all.
Although progress was made during this administration, the kind of groundbreaking and innovative policies like those of the early 1970’s remain elusive for current leadership. Not mentioned in this article was the closest that President Biden came to this type of transformative action: The Inflation Reduction Act, which represents a significant step in the right direction of America’s climate future. Rebuilding environmental policy after the Trump Administration was no small feat, and while the Biden Administration was far from perfect, they have proven that, while change may not be linear, forward movement is always possible.