The Judiciary and the Environment
Once enacted, environmental policies are subject to interpretation. It is the role of the courts to determine the extent to which a policy can be enforced in a specific situation. The courts are themselves bound by previous rulings but as in the case of Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council (1984,) previous rulings can be overturned, having significant effects. Through interpreting the law, the courts are able to have a huge impact on private ventures. In my example from week 1, the Supreme Court issued an injunction against the building of the Tellico Dam in Tennessee, arguing that the Endangered Species Act of 1973 lawfully protected the trout population that the construction project would have harmed.
During the first 20 years of the environmental movement, the judiciary tended to favor environmental groups, hearing lawsuits from advocacy groups and also providing a platform for environmentalists to make their concerns heard by the general public. In the 1990’s however the court began to shift its focus to upholding business interests. During the administration of George W. Bush, the Supreme Court became even more opposed to government environmental regulations. It was during the administration of George W. Bush, though, that environmental advocacy groups sued the EPA for failing to regulate carbon dioxide, which they argued the government needed to combat under the terms of the 1963 Clean Air Act. In 2007, Massachusetts v. EPA was brought before the Supreme Court. The court ruled 5-4 that the CAA did, in fact, apply to carbon dioxide and that it was the government’s responsibility to take measures to alleviate it.
During the Biden administration, the conservative majority Supreme Court challenged the authority of the EPA and other federal agencies to regulate business activity. Recently, conservatives have argued that only elected officials have the legal authority to regulate the private sector and that non-elected bureaucrats have no legal grounds for interfering in American industry. Last year, SCOTUS was able to use this argument to pause the EPA’s enforcement of regulations meant to fight air pollution. These talking points also allowed the court to overturn the ruling of the 1984 case, Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council, which legally obligated the judiciary to allow federal agencies to exercise their authority in implementing policies they believed to be consistent with the will of Congress. This law had previously been the basis for the EPA to function. Robert Percival, an environmental law professor at the University of Maryland, claims that the overturning of Chevron sets a precedent for the Supreme Court continuing to use its judicial power to limit the authority of the EPA, resisting environmental protections (Joselow 2024.)
Although environmental lawsuits seldom make it to the Supreme Court, these instances where the Endangered Species Act, the Clean Air Act, and the Chevron doctrine were brought into national attention and analyzed show how the whole judiciary, across all levels, has the power to alter the way environmental laws are enforced and even the very authority of the entities who can enforce them. In all cases, the interpretation of policies ended up being as important as the policies themselves and have a binding impact on the actions of other branches of government.
Citations:
Joselow, Maxine. “How Conservative Judges Secured a ‘Chain Saw’ to Derail Environmental Rules.” The Washington Post, July 1, 2024.
(Edited to discuss recent developments)
One reply on “The Judiciary and the Environment”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Hi James,
Judicial implications are critical for shaping environmental policy. In the Supreme Court, it demonstrates that courts have the power to influence both the enforcement and scope of environmental laws. Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council highlights how shifting judicial perspectives can impact environmental protection efforts. The challenge of agencies like the EPA under Biden displays how judicial decisions can restrict or expand federal regulations. Ultimately, judicial interpretations shape the capacity of government agencies to enforce policies and reflect broader political shifts in the judicial branch.