Week 4: Ecological Democracy

As noted in the assigned readings, there is an apparent discrepancy between the need to uphold the principles of democracy and the need to create a sustainable future. As discussed in the Environmental Values reading, democracy is by its nature open-ended and so its outcomes can be either environmentally positive or destructive depending on the will of the people. There are many American voters who do not see sustainability as in their best interests. There are even those who view it as at odds with their well-being. Corporate media outlets stoke public paranoia that emissions reduction laws exist to control what Americans can drive and that the protection of endangered lands is solely to extend government control. This framing of environmental protections as jeopardizing individual liberties is a huge obstacle in realizing an ecological democracy. As Mitchell discussed, it is often accompanied by a mistrust of qualified experts. For democracy to serve the needs of the environment, there must be a profound shift in public perception of individual rights and how they relate to sustainability. Rather than seeing environmental policies as a zero-sum game between the people and the planet, these two interests need to be seen as interdependent.

In modern American society, the concept of individual rights is hard to divorce from capitalism. Americans push back against the idea of their consumption being limited in any way. Marit Hammond, in the Polychroniou interview, is correct to discuss the difficulty if not the impossibility of reconciling sustainability with a system that prioritizes growth. While she states that long-term economic stability, even under capitalism, would require more sustainable uses of resources and would thus benefit from environmental regulations, it is difficult to imagine our current society beginning to widely look at things from a long-term perspective when immediate needs seem to be more pressing. Marit, speaking in 2019, appears to be optimistic that younger generations are more environmentally conscious, which might result in their genuine interest in supporting environmentally friendly political candidates. At this point, though, I wonder whether this trend is reversing. The more ‘alternative’ information is promoted online, the more I fear pseudo-science and climate skepticism will increase as influencers of future voters.

This being said, I think the one hope for the realization of an ecological democracy is an active popular movement which resists the promotion of both pseudo-science and the corporate influences on politicians. Naturally, an educated citizenry is in a better position to vote and if it is to become the genuine will of the American public to choose a more sustainable future, there would need to be additional measures for private citizens to educate other private citizens, showing the importance of environmental protection not only for its own sake but for the well-being of future citizens.

2 replies on “Week 4: Ecological Democracy”

  1. Lily Hooge on

    Hello James, I agree with you that the rise in pseudo-science and mis/disinformation is scary on a good day, and makes me want to give up on others. I think, though, that we can’t expect people who are simply vulnerable and victims of this misinformation to start changing their ways and doing better research. Scientists and science communicators need to look into the root cause of why people are trying to seek out these ‘alternative facts’ to deal with their current realities. It is so much easier to blame Biden for rising egg prices instead of a complex economic process that is caused by everything from residual COVID inflation to the rise in bird flu. Science communicators need to get off high horses and starting finding ways to make science and truth more accessible to the American public.

  2. Clint Cole on

    You have raised important points about tension between democratic values and sustainability. Corporate media shapes policies in all areas and their influence in shaping environmental policies cannot go unnoticed. Their influence in framing environmental policies as threat to personal freedom causes public skepticism and this makes ecological democracy a mirage. Changing public perception is important to enable them see the importance of protecting environment and advocating for sustainability. Your emphasis on grassroots education is important as it will create the needed awareness that is important to enhance trust and community engagement. It is important to counter misinformation and creating a more informed movement that is important t boost a democratic environmental action.

Leave a Reply