EJ or just bad business?

                  Rosenbaum defined environmental justice with three distinct principles: procedural rules not being applied uniformly, a social inequity based on racial bias, and a geographic inequity. In the first round of environmental impact statements on the Ambler Road, I believe environmental justice was certainly called into question. First, the BLM did a pitiful job of consulting with communities and tribes (as determined by a federal judge: this is procedural rules not be applied correctly. And third, a social inequity existed because local, largely Iñupiaq and Athabascan communities have been disenfranchised for generations in favor of the US government extracting the whale oil or muskrat hides or minerals as it wishes. As a result, locals often lack the trust and know-how to engage in lengthy federal processes. I believe that the BLM’s Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement process largely rectified these issues.

                  I’m struggling a little bit to engage with the geographic inequity concept. Yes, the BLM arbitrarily decided to designate the Upper Kobuk as an area where it was acceptable to degrade the environment in favor of mining interests. But then no matter where the project would be located, a geographic inequity could exist? There is the argument that mining projects are often located near Indigenous communities that are far away from centers of population. However, I think the counterargument to be made is that the Upper Kobuk is fully 150 miles and two watersheds removed from the nearest mine.

Ok, waxing aside, in this week’s readings on environmental justice I kept thinking about the Trump Administration removing DEI language and websites and ending programs related to certain groups’ interests. I can’t help but wonder if environmental justice could be in the crosshairs soon, as it was in Trump’s first term.

Many environmental causes in Alaska are described as “environmental justice” issues lately. I’ve heard this term to describe Ambler Road as well as Pebble Mine, oil leases in the Arctic Refuge, and more. In the coming months and years, it may make more sense for activists, decision-makers, etc. to lean on economic reasoning to oppose these projects. And it’s pretty easy to oppose the economics of these projects.

 If the Trump Administration is truly concerned with outsized federal spending and the State of Alaska truly needs to cut the budget, NOT spending millions to prop up AIDEA and subsidize oil leases and Ambler Road is an excellent first step. Yes, let the government step back and NOT provide tax cuts to oil and mining companies to entice them to stay in Alaska making billions. It doesn’t need to be an environmental justice issue, just bad business.

2 replies on “EJ or just bad business?”

  1. Ryan Rose on

    I think there’s some good things to be said here about leveraging campaign promises on economics to smuggle in environmental justice issues, but I wonder how effective that can be in the long run? Often environmental justice is ignored through claims that decisions are simply ‘good business’. Still, if it works in any one case it’s worth the try, especially with wins being so hard to find.

  2. Lily Hooge on

    Hi China! You brought up a really good point in your last paragraph about bad business. It’s something I’ve been thinking about too, even if it’s not directly tied to this week’s topics of environmental justice and risk. While the world and economy are evolving, the Trump administration seems fixated on reviving outdated industries instead of adapting to new realities. Oil will likely stick around for a few more decades, but Alaska—and Trump’s efforts to prop up the oil industry with billions in tax cuts really underscores your idea of bad business. If these industries are as profitable as they claim, why do they need so much government support? It seems clear that the oil industry is in decline, despite the far right’s resistance to change. We should instead welcome a new era of more profitable, sustainable energy production that reflects where the economy is truly headed.

Leave a Reply