Week 6: Taking the Will of Environmental Justice for the Deed
There is an interview I found quite some time ago between the activist and writer James Baldwin and the philosophy professor Paul Weiss. It is a very old interview, but what is so striking about it is how modern it feels. It was recorded when Ronald Reagan was known as Governor Reagan, but the discussions about race and economic prosperity are near word for word exactly still what we hear today, though perhaps more “civil”. In this, near the end, Baldwin makes a final point: “you are asking me to do the impossible, you are asking me to take the Will for the Deed.” He then goes on to state how perhaps he cannot know whether the labour boards, realtors, educators, and such of this country are racist, but he can tell you what unions black people cannot join, what ghettos black people live in, and what schools black kids, his kids, can go to. “You want me to make an act of faith, risking myself… on some idealism which you assure me exists in America which I have never seen.”
Now of course I know that not all environmental justice issues are racial issues, that there can be many degrees of separation between the two, but the fact remains that many breeches of environmental justice mirror the same ugly problems. The only difference is that environmental justice, being newer and having a less ugly history, is not met with the same degree of two-faced platitudes. The promise of environmental justice is not proclaimed as American in the same way the promise of equality is, and the structure of our country and legal system well show this.
While we all can agree that everyone should have clean water and clean air, but, as shown in cases like Flint, our systems can be woefully incompetent in providing those things to people whom are too poor to provide themselves or demand they be provided. Even more so, we see that over sites, once done, are nigh impossible to credibly rebuke or repay for. The demand that we find a single person, deliberately and openly at fault, shields the ever increasingly complex bodies of power that can obfuscate any decision from one point of failure. Entire communities can be placed, more or less strategically, around dumps and pollution sites without any one person being responsible. Entire cities can be given visibly brown and poisoned water, so full of iron that instruments are maxed, without a single responsible party.
The fact that many people directly associated with the Flint Water Crisis cannot be successfully prosecuted for any crime is not a bug: it is a feature. It is the same feature that has been used from decades to stall out much of any meaningful civil rights progress because it is easier to say that things are already done and too complicated to be undone than it is to say that those things done were wrong and are still wrong to this day. We admit that ‘yes, we could do better’, and we say ‘well of course, from now on this won’t happen again’, but we still don’t rectify the original sins nor do we adequate apply justice to those who, while not responsible for them, leverage and utilize those sins all the same.
Environmental Justice, as it stands, is woefully disregarded in this country because we have a lot of wills and very little deeds. While this administration will certainly take away even those wills, it is a shame that we have very little deeds for him even to take back. It is a difficult conversation, and there are certain values to weighed against, but everyone, everyone single citizen, deserves a right to environmental justice. We have systems for public response but almost none for public input and even less on public engagement. As seen in Flint, it is incredibly easy for governments to simply ignore citizen concerns because they have numbers to achieve, not goals to satisfy. Environmental justice means being conscious of environmental impacts at all stages of civil operations, governmental and commercial. Environmental justice needs to be proactive in achieving and enforcing its goals across society. We need to stop having the Will and start providing the deed.
3 replies on “Week 6: Taking the Will of Environmental Justice for the Deed”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Hey, Ryan. I really appreciate your discussion of will vs. deed. There seems to be a lot of misplaced optimism in regards to any sort of justice movement in the United States. There is this assumption that issues just sort themselves out without actions simply because the public has the will for that to happen. This was largely the case during the Civil Rights Movement, where activists were criticized for being rabble-rousers and not acknowledged as the agents of change. I still hear some people say that racism diminished in America naturally and that activists have had little influence. This baseless thinking extends to all levels of activism, including environmental. The same assumption exists that policies are not needed to combat climate change and that the will of the people will fix it. This is one key thing I think unites different justice movements and why they are necessarily interrelated.
Hi Ryan, I think your post and James’ go very well together. James discussed the disproportionate impact on marginalized groups, also highlighting the Flint Water Crisis. I agree with your analysis on why the problem is not being solved and why nothing is being done to prosecute those responsible for it. I would just add that there is likely a degree of complacency that can be attributed to this problem and a sense of “that’s not my problem, I don’t care.”
Hi Ryan, failures like the Flint Water Crisis are tragic, they don’t necessarily prove that environmental justice is intentionally rigged against the poor. Bureaucratic inefficiency and poor governance impact communities across all income levels, as seen in disasters like the Porter Ranch gas leak and the Malibu fires. Instead of assuming systemic injustice, there could be a higher focus on improving accountability and ensuring all communities receive the resources they need. Do you think the multi level bureaucratic system is the best way do prevent and respond to environmental catastrophes?