Week 4: NEPA
I’m a little late to the party as I was away on a work trip for the last two weeks, but on the bright side I feel like I have a little bit more to talk about on this topic given Trump’s continuation of Executive Orders undoing years of progress. In particular, I came across a Forbes article that I feel sums up the problem with NEPA that Trump is exploiting. NEPA has suffered from the same pitfall that many acts have suffered from and that is vague language in order to offend as few people as possible just to get the bill to pass. In doing so, that leaves a lot of decisions up to the Executive branch. Therefore, Trump is well within his rights to make adjustments to the implementation of NEPA. Is bureaucracy slow? Yes. Can the process be streamlined? Probably. Should NEPA be repealed in order to expedite government projects? No, we still need some sort of regulation when it comes to environmental impact of government projects.
Playing Devil’s Advocate for a moment, I can see how cutting NEPA restrictions can result in (short term) gains by saving money. First, there is the cost of the employees that are conducting the assessments. Second, the cost of the project. I’m sure while the project is in limbo awaiting an environmental impact evaluation it is costing the government money in some way, shape, or form. Finally, if environmental impacts are not a concern, the government does not have to spend extra money on mitigating environmental impacts. Saving all of this money sounds great if you are around 80 years old and are not expecting to live more than 20 more years to see all of the negative impacts of disregarding the environment.
2 replies on “Week 4: NEPA”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Hello Brandon, I like that you bring up the executive orders that have been issued as a method to reduce spending. Removing thousands of federal employees, ending government research, and halting programs is an extremely fast way to reduce government spending. Most definitely a short term bandaid to make voters happy, this will not bring any good for the environment.
Hi Brandon. I appreciated that you pointed out that vague language can often be used as a tool to get these issues through Congress quickly or with widespread support, yet also empowers certain sects of government to potentially exploit their oversight.
The biggest issue that I see with the cutting of research looking into environmental concerns and helping inform policies which apply to and fund mitigation efforts is that this will result in more federal spending when communities are struck by disasters that could have potentially been mitigated or diminished in casualties due to proper preparation. I’m thinking of the landslides in Southeast Alaska and monitoring done there to protect communities from the deadly disasters which have taken multiple lives (including an entire family in Wrangell) in recent years.