Sturgeon case and hunting regulations

One of the public lands conflicts that has most gripped my attention recently is the Sturgeon case, due to its impact on hunting regulations around the state (and particularly in Northwest Arctic). Prior to 2019, it was illegal for non-federally qualified subsistence users to hunt in Kobuk Valley National Park. Period. Today, this all depends on the definition of navigable waters.

In 2007, John Sturgeon was using a hovercraft in Yukon Charlie National Park. The Park Service had banned hovercrafts, but Sturgeon argued that the river was state land and that the State allowed hovercrafts. Two courts ruled in favor of the Park Service before the Supreme Court ruled in favor of Sturgeon. As a result, navigable waters inside parks and federal lands boundaries are now considered state property and rules are enforced by the state.

However, as we have read in this class, the definition of navigable waters (WOTUS) is highly contested in Washington, DC. After the Sturgeon case, the State and the feds have released conflicting maps of navigable waters in Alaska. The State, of course, claims that almost all tributaries of the Noatak and Kobuk Rivers are “navigable.” Meanwhile, the feds show significantly fewer navigable waterways and many questionable tributaries. BLM is the agency tasked with designating navigable waterways—and they have their work cut out for them in Alaska. Surveying all these rivers and creeks costs a tremendous amount of money, staff time, and other resources to execute field trips and paperwork needed. As a result, the navigable waterways issue has hardly progressed beyond the State of Alaska claiming that most waterways are navigable, and therefore State-controlled.

This decision has myriad implications for development and hunting regulations in Alaska. For example, the State could allow dredge-suction mining on navigable waters inside national park lands. The impact on hunting regulations is perhaps more contentious.

In the Northwest Arctic since Sturgeon, concern brews that hunters from outside of the region or even outside of the state, could land along the Kobuk or Noatak Rivers and hunt caribou alongside the federally-qualified subsistence users who live there. On the other side, hunters from outside the region who come in for their once-in-a-lifetime, super expensive hunt, question whether their shot needs to be within navigable waterways or if the animal needs to fall below the mean high water line, etc. Some hunters appear to play a game of chicken with federal law enforcement to see how much they will err on the side of caution.

Regardless, the people of Alaska also seem divided on this issue. Most people in Northwest Arctic and rural areas would prefer to have federal hunting regulations as they are given subsistence preference. Many people in the more populated areas of the state would prefer additional state lands from which to hunt, fish and commercialize.

Unfortunately, I don’t think this an issue that will be resolved in the near future as the BLM has many mandates in addition to designating navigable waters. Meanwhile the Department of Interior workforce is in the process of being whittled away at. I have heard speculation that while the State hopes to claim more territory in the form of waterways, it could almost be against their best interests that the BLM complete its surveys. Instead, the State could potentially gain more power by backing another case similar to the one brought by Sturgeon.

2 replies on “Sturgeon case and hunting regulations”

  1. Cynphany Henderson on

    The Sturgeon case has drawn attention to the relationships amongst state and federal land management in Alaska. Before the case, non-federally qualified subsistence livers could not hunt in places such as Kobuk Valley National Park. This case showed how much power the state can have when managing water rights and hunting grounds. With state and federal maps constantly going back and forth, the BLM has been carrying out surveys, which can be time-consuming and expensive. Like you said, the decision can lead to activities like mining within national parks, and this can worry people. The issue can be split in two ways in Alaska. Rural areas want to preserve regulations, and urban areas want more government interference when hunting on particular land.

  2. Jay Clapeck on

    There is a Utah’s lawsuit that mirrors the Sturgeon case in Alaska, challenging federal authority over vast public spaces. While the state argues this would boost economic opportunities like grazing and mining, federal management helps preserve public access and environmental protections. If Utah wins, it could set a precedent for other states, potentially leading to land privatization and restricted use. Should public lands be managed for state interests, or remain federally protected for all Americans?

Leave a Reply