Week 7: Public Lands and Oil

Reading the graduate article this week on the Dakota Access Pipeline and the complex issues surrounding it made me think about how much the oil industry has influenced policymaking and decisions surrounding public land acquisition over the last century. There was a line in the article that talked about pipelines and the innate politics of oil and it really struck me:

“Pipelines – by design – were never meant to be political but rather technical objects best governed by industry actors, experts, and administrators. Regulators and industry actors have reinforced the perception of pipelines as technical objects through the development of an extensive suite of standards regulating pipeline/utility development.”

This talk of pipelines as a “technical object” rather than something that deeply disrupts the natural environment upset me. As we hear about proposed development policies and the expansion of oil exploration in Arctic Alaska, I think it is important to remember not only the impact upon the environment that creating a pipeline creates (permanently altering the natural world and putting it at constant risk of contamination) but also the fact that this kind of pervasive development further alienates them as the Public from accessing the benefits of natural and wildness.

I understand where the pro-development mindset comes from. I know our state is failing and underfunded. What I don’t understand is how we aren’t coming up with more expansive policy solutions.

Another thing I appreciated about the graduate reading article was how the authors acknowledged that “difficulties associated with public participation reflect a broader depoliticatization of environmental governance wherein complex political issues are reduced to technical problems that require expert-informed solutions managed by administrative agencies.” This seems to exemplify the unfortunate public consensus that these things are out of our hands and uncontrollable, when that is entirely not true.

I do think that there is a turning tide of people realizing how important raising their voice is in a representative democracy. I’m hopeful that either way, we can come together to manage Alaska’s public lands and resources with a conscious eye towards future generations.

2 replies on “Week 7: Public Lands and Oil”

  1. James Carr on

    Hello, Chloe. I agree, it seems like sometimes infrastructure growth is just taken for granted. People don’t see a construction project and think of it through a political lens. When it happens to be something, like an oil pipeline, which is deeply tied to power dynamics within politics, people lack the knowledge and skills to feel like they can make a difference. Being proactive and getting into a mindset of civic involvement could be helpful for when situations begin that make public influence essential.

  2. Clint Cole on

    You reflection highlights important points showing the link between environmental governance and public participation. Framing of pipelines as technical objects fails to acknowledge the social, cultural and ecological impacts of these projects on communities and landscapes. This mindset is not good as it marginalizes public voices yet they are important stakeholders. Communities deserve inclusive policies that gives priority sustainability and economic stability. The policies should also focus on empowering communities to improve their participation which is important to ensure long-term sustainability and economic development.

Leave a Reply