Value Conflicts in the Fairbanks Community
Value management is one of my favorite topics when we talk about land conflict. What do we value as a society, as individuals? What is the difference between active values (like views, money, etc) versus the passive ones we use every day but don’t think about (clean air, water, regulating services). Even tougher, is balancing often individualistic mindsets with collective resources or issues without clear borders.
While I grew up in Alaska, I grew up in a federal government family, with both of my parents having careers in the National Park Service. Coming to Fairbanks from there, I had a tough reality check as I realized that there are many Alaskans, and quite a few Fairbanksians, who believe that the federal government has no right managing the lands they currently oversee. There are so many interesting ways to look at this issue, but I will take on just one group for this blog post.
The Alaska Alpine Club is one of UAF’s oldest clubs. It has represented the Fairbanks mountain community since the 1950s, with many of the club’s board members making first ascents up routes on Denali, climbing peaks for the first time in the Delta Range, and creating huts and other public infrastructure across the interior. In 1979, the Denali National Park Service started a climbing fee for Denali. This fee paid the salaries for rangers who are stationed at the camps on the mountain and covered the cost of rescues, acting as a form of insurance. While some private volunteer rescue services existed on the mountain, as the land managers for the area, the park service felt responsible for climber’s safety and that it was their duty to create a safe, comprehensive rescue system. A collection of members of the Alaska Alpine Club disagreed vehemently with this decision, as they believed that, as public land, access to Denali and any other mountain should be free of any restrictions or registration (Alaska Alpine Club). With the slogan “Go Home National Park Service” this faction left the club to form the Alaskan (emphasis on the ‘n’) Alpine Club. Today, according to current members of the Alaska Alpine Club, the Alaskan Alpine Club is now a loose collection of older men heeing and hawing in their cabins about the old ways, while the Alaska Alpine Club tries to uphold their values and responsibilities as representatives of the Interior climbing community.
It is my belief that because of the inherent ways of human nature, we must hold our valuable resources in trust for the greater good, and that most NPS, Forest Service, BLM, etc employees are dedicated to access and preservation of the resources, not preventing reasonable recreation. If we do let these responsibilities fall into private hands, whether it be land management or rescue insurance, we risk grave consequences, such as inflated prices of access and non-comprehensive rescue operations. We must work to uplift and improve our land management systems if we want to see more equitable access, not tear them down.
The link to the Alaska Alpine Club history if you are interested: https://www.alaskaalpineclub.com/clubhistoryThe link to the Alaskan Alpine Club website: https://alaskanalpineclub.org/.