Week 2 Response
Sam Zeno focuses largely on two forces in environmental decision-making in the article: organized interests and the executive branch. According to the article, many of Biden’s conservation actions have widespread public support and were recommended by tribes and environmental organizations. This aligns well with Rosenbaum’s description as he notes that organized interests have unique access to policy making and implementation under the US constitution. I believe Zeno would argue that the Biden Administration took this a step further with its unprecedented support for tribal interests and the access it afforded to environmental activists in decision-making processes.
Although Biden’s robust environmental agenda was significantly eaten away at by Congress’s pens, Zeno believes that the systematic formulation and implementation of environmental policy is to thank for much of the Administration’s success. This includes its conservation spending made possible through the Inflation Reduction Act and Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, as well as the administrative priority of the America the Beautiful Initiative. The Department of Interior had a lot of heavily publicized conservation decisions on its plate and President Biden created five national monuments through the Antiquities Act. In short, Biden’s conservation goals appear to have been a highly coordinated effort within his administration. However, Zeno’s article neglects to mention that while difficult to work with, Congress did pass multiple major spending packages proposed by Biden. And Zeno avoids the fact that a significant number of Biden’s decisions are potentially reversible by the next president.
Biden, therefore, met the most success in environmental policy through administrative means. Congress passed some of his legislative priorities. And the Supreme Court was downright hostile to the environmental and other regulatory powers of government agencies in the overturn of the Chevron doctrine.
In the end, I would rank Biden as somewhat successful in enacting his environmental agenda. His initial Build Back Better plan focused on clean energy and while the Administration was successful in boosting the clean energy sector, compromises in Congress definitely hampered its original intentions. As for the conservation portion of his goals, many of Biden’s actions can easily be reversed by Trump. The national monuments designated by Biden could take just another executive order to be undone—as was the case in Trump’s first term. While the solicitor’s office of DOI worked hard to ensure that the department’s decisions would hold up in expected future lawsuits, decisions such as the Ambler Road and D-1 lands in Alaska, informed by robust science and extensive public hearings, are already being called into question. Due to the question of permanence, I would characterize much of the environmental policies of the last four years are examples of incrementalism. In addition, though Zeno describes a large degree of public support for conservation, that is certainly missing in Congress. Without Congressional support for conservation and environmental action, it is difficult for lasting regulations, such as in the 70s, to be made.