Week 3 – Judicial vs. Executive Branch
Under the past 3 presidential administrations, environmental policy has been a focus of executive orders and other actions in each president’s early days in office. As the federal government switches between Democratic and Republican administrations, differing views on environmental policy cause presidents to essentially undo everything the previous president did. For example, Trump withdrew from the Paris Climate Agreement in 2017, and again in 2025, after Biden rejoined the agreement in 2021.
While it is the president’s right to enact policy change in line with their policy agendas, the desire to immediately undo the last administration’s actions can sometimes lead to executive orders and other policies being passed without completing proper due diligence. This is where the courts step in. Federal Courts/judges can block executive orders that they deem unconstitutional or otherwise problematic. While this usually only causes a temporary stay, that can be enough time for other legal entities and citizen advocates to organize and create a stronger argument.
While not necessarily environmental policy-related, Trump’s federal funding freeze and federal hiring freeze certainly affect environmental institutions such as the EPA. Due to the questionable legality of the federal funding freeze, U.S. District Judge Loren L. AliKhan blocked the freeze minutes before it was set to take effect, causing an administrative stay. This is one way the judicial branch can check the executive branch’s power, preventing it from fully undoing all of a previous administration’s policies illegally.
2 replies on “Week 3 – Judicial vs. Executive Branch”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Hi Lily!
I liked how you highlighted the issue that takes place in US environmental policies: the constant shift between Democratic and Republican ideologies causing parties to undo actions, resulting in back-and-forth battles. This makes it difficult to move forward with progress. Yes, the president can make executive orders, but this may lead to hasty decisions. The situation where the courts froze Trump’s funding plays an important role in checking the executive power. This way, checks and balances can ensure actions taken by the President are constitutional and are grounded in proper reasoning. Judicial oversight is crucial in maintaining the laws and regulations to prevent abrupt and potentially harmful moves in policy.
Hey Lily, this is a really good point, especially the back-and-forth between administrations. It shows how unstable environmental policy can be when it’s driven so heavily by executive action, and why the courts end up playing such a big role in slowing things down or checking power.