Skepticism
I had a hard time with this set of “environmental/ecological democracy” readings because it feels so far off from what we are seeing in American democracy and many other governments and societies around the world.
But I found a glimmer of hope, or at least opportunity, in the facilitating factor of perceptions of environmental crisis. Mitchell says that if people consider themselves as under environmental threat, they are more interested in participating in relevant democratic processes. Furthermore, people tend to be more activated at the local level.
The Northwest Arctic provides anecdotes for this factor. In the late 90s and early 2000s, few people were talking about climate change here, despite warnings from scientists, Al Gore, and even a very few locals. As time went on, more and more people became impacted by climate events or saw the effects. For example, the villages of Kivalina and Kotzebue have increased coastal erosion. As a result, Kivalina tribe is searching for funding and developers to relocate their village and Kotzebue built a seawall. Another example lies in caribou. In the late 90s and early 2000s, there were almost a half million caribou in the regional herd. As the numbers have rapidly declined, suddenly everyone is a caribou expert and has an opinion on why the decline is happening and the proper solution. Furthermore, people are taking part in participatory democracy processes to protect the herd (Board of Game and Western Arctic Caribou Herd Working Group meetings, anti Ambler Road advocacy, continued withdrawal of D-1 Lands, etc.)
This seems like a no-brainer—of course people are more worried about toxins or storms that affect their own children than a wildfire two thousand miles away. This is why I was surprised that in Marit Hammond’s interview she specifically mentions Fridays for Future and Extinction Rebellion as strong players in bringing us toward ecological democracy. I believe Hammond’s argument is that these groups can help us create new structures for participatory democracy. Hammond also believes that everyone needs to be involved, these need to be inclusive spaces. But these are two organizations with a global focus—pretty hard for most people to feel activated by this broad cause unless they are already strong climate advocates. And regardless, I can’t imagine “Joe the Plumber” being involved in a group like Extinction Rebellion.
While Joe the Plumber might not believe in climate change, I am certain that he feels connected to a park or meadow or crisp fall day in his vicinity. I believe power lies in smaller, more local groups that feel connected to a specific ecosystem. Trends are also on our side here: as climate impacts increase, more people will be activated in this arena.
This still leaves me with questions: will that be too late? And how much will the solutions that come out of those processes really help?
While Mitchell provides an example of community-led forestry practices in Mexico, I’m thinking of the caribou and seawall examples closer to home. In the case of caribou, we did successfully reduce harvest limits. But many believe that we did not reduce them nearly enough to have an impact. And the seawall feels like a giant band-aid on the bigger issue of long-term sea level rise. Is this the fault of the process or our own imaginations?
2 replies on “Skepticism”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Hello, China. I share your feelings of having a hard time envisioning widespread concern for environmental issues given the current state of the country. I appreciate your consideration for the idea that people need to view environmental destruction as immediately impacting them, which can relate to their local wildlife areas. Personalizing the issue, in a way, seems like the most effective way to democratically make people more concerned with involvement in climate action.
I really appreciate the line you wrote: “I believe power lies in smaller, more local groups that feel connected to a specific ecosystem.” Many Alaskans, myself included, share your frustrations with wildlife management. From King Salmon to Caribou, our resources have been mismanaged. Control over these natural resources should be returned to the state government—Alaskans know what’s best for Alaska. This shift would ensure that input from Alaska Natives, local communities, outdoorsmen, and lifelong residents is prioritized, leading to more effective and sustainable management.