Public Lands Conflicts
The laying of oil pipelines through public lands is a contentious issue. The legal structure has made it so that non-expert citizens have little influence over permissions to build oil pipelines or other energy infrastructure. Decisions have been made mostly by state governments, oil companies, and government agencies. This seems undemocratic, considering that these decisions are believed to have a major impact on public land. Non-experts weighing in has been viewed as unnecessary, not useful, and impeding progress. This has also made it so that incumbent energy producers, mostly petroleum based, have been able to dominate the market. In order to make their voices heard, citizens will often form alliances with environmental groups. This is the only realistic way of challenging powerful interests. In 2015, Tabitha Tripp, an opponent to the Dakota Access Pipeline (through Illinois,) was able to challenge existing legal frameworks and increase public involvement against the project. To do this, she joined forces with the Sierra Club and the Natural Resources Defense Council, who helped to fund her efforts. Her organization, SOIL (Save Our Illinois Land,) has made efforts to promote sustainable infrastructure in Illinois, which has led to more public involvement. This democratization can work for both sides, however. In the case of oil pipelines, this sort of petroleum infrastructure is seen by much of the public as a means of reducing costs for oil and other products. It is also linked to job creation. This being said, any public lands dispute that involves the public needs to involve the entire public. This situation is strikingly similar to that in Cape Cod, where different members of the general public held different positions on whether or not the building of off-shore windmills was in their best interest. What makes these cases similar is that public involvement ended up leading to a longer dispute. If proceedings had remained at a much higher level, cut off from public influence, chances are they would not have taken so long. This is a necessary trade-off whenever public lands are at stake.
One reply on “Public Lands Conflicts”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
James, great post. I agree that NGOs are one of the most effective ways for the average citizen to have a voice in large scale projects like the ones you mentioned. However, do you think there should be a more democratic approach, such as placing greater emphasis on citizen voting rather than relying solely on legislative actions?