Week 7: Public Lands
Public lands are currently a very contentious topic, apparently. Seemingly, a substantial amount of people do not place value in public lands and their stewardship, as our federal government has decided to do away with much of the staff and funding for protection and upkeep of these places. Who gets to decide whether land has value or not?
Generally, public land in America can be visualized as a vast, untouched landscape that is set aside for conservation and for the benefit of future generations being able to experience the wildness that previous generations did. However, the idea that these “pristine” lands should remain separate from human activity is complicated, artificial, and can be harmful. This perspective shapes the management of public land, and, in the case of Cape Wind, public water, and prioritizes elite visions of nature over the needs of Indigenous people, local communities, and even climate crisis mitigation.
For centuries, U.S. public lands have been a battleground for conservationists, developers, Indigenous peoples, and many other groups. National Parks such as Yellowstone were only created through the removal of Native peoples, which further reinforced the perspective of public land only being valuable without impact by humans. The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, for example, exists within the modern zeitgeist as an untouched area free from human development and impact. While it is true that this area has been protected from large scale development, this framing ignores Indigenous people and their hundreds of years of impact on this land.
At the same, public lands are becoming places that are only accessible to the wealthy. For example, national parks out west; Colorado or Montana ski areas such as Aspen or Big Sky; and classically valued areas like the Nantucket Sound, as depicted in the Cape Wind film. Opposition to the Cape Wind project depicted the ways that elite homeowners were able to leverage environmental laws to block protect their ocean views, while also blocking development of more environmentally sustainable energy sources.
If public lands are truly public, there needs to be an evening out of accessibility to these lands. The public, rather than just a select few with money and power in the region, need to be involved in the decision making about public lands. This is the gold standard in most democratic spaces today, but an effort needs to be made to even out the power of different voices within the decision-making process of “public” lands.
Generally, public land in America can be visualized as a vast, untouched landscape that is set aside for conservation and for the benefit of future generations being able to experience the wildness that previous generations did. However, the idea that these “pristine” lands should remain separate from human activity is complicated, artificial, and can be harmful. This perspective shapes the management of public land, and, in the case of Cape Wind, public water, and prioritizes elite visions of nature over the needs of Indigenous people, local communities, and even climate crisis mitigation.
For centuries, U.S. public lands have been a battleground for conservationists, developers, Indigenous peoples, and many other groups. National Parks such as Yellowstone were only created through the removal of Native peoples, which further reinforced the perspective of public land only being valuable without impact by humans. The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, for example, exists within the modern zeitgeist as an untouched area free from human development and impact. While it is true that this area has been protected from large scale development, this framing ignores Indigenous people and their hundreds of years of impact on this land.
At the same, public lands are becoming places that are only accessible to the wealthy. For example, national parks out west; Colorado or Montana ski areas such as Aspen or Big Sky; and classically valued areas like the Nantucket Sound, as depicted in the Cape Wind film. Opposition to the Cape Wind project depicted the ways that elite homeowners were able to leverage environmental laws to block protect their ocean views, while also blocking development of more environmentally sustainable energy sources.
If public lands are truly public, there needs to be an evening out of accessibility to these lands. The public, rather than just a select few with money and power in the region, need to be involved in the decision making about public lands. This is the gold standard in most democratic spaces today, but an effort needs to be made to even out the power of different voices within the decision-making process of “public” lands.
2 replies on “Week 7: Public Lands”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Hi Gwen, thank you for your valuable insight. I agree that public land is not fairly public to everyone. It is odd to characterize land as public and private, as the nature of land is limitless. I am not sure how we can increase access and quality of land for everyone, but I do agree it is needed. Everyone deserves access to green space, and this isn’t possible if we privatize our land.
You ask a good question: Who determines the value of public property?
Public lands have long been constructed as “pristine” and apart from human impact, erasing Indigenous histories and connections. This imagined construct serves elite interests over wider public interests, as with Cape Wind, where affluent homeowners stalled renewable energy development.
Accessibility is also a concern—public land increasingly is ground for the affluent, whether it is ski resorts or gated communities. Real public land management must have a diversity of voices, not merely the powerful and monied.